Tata Trusts, the philanthropic institution that holds a commanding majority stake in Tata Sons, is facing an unusual and increasingly visible governance rift. The term of trustee Mehli Mistry is nearing expiration on October 28, and senior trustees, including Chairman Noel Tata, Vice-Chairman Venu Srinivasan, and Vijay Singh, are unlikely to support his renewal. The shift marks a departure from the Trusts’ long-standing practice of unanimous approvals for trustee continuity.
This dispute comes on the heels of a flashpoint in September, when the Trusts voted against reappointing 77-year-old Vijay Singh to the Tata Sons board, an unprecedented decision in the Trusts’ recent history. Four trustees, including Mistry, opposed Singh’s continuation, citing concerns about governance norms, board representation, and strategic alignment at Tata Sons. The episode exposed two distinct schools of thought within the Trusts.
One faction, associated with Mistry, has argued for a stronger and more assertive voice for the Trusts at the Tata Sons board level, particularly as the group prepares to resolve the planned exit of minority shareholder Shapoorji Pallonji Group. The opposing faction, led by Noel Tata and Srinivasan, favours continuity of board leadership and a consensus-driven approach to preserve institutional stability and avoid signaling internal discord.
The tensions heightened further when Mistry indicated that his own renewal should be linked to unanimous trustee approvals for future reappointments, which is viewed by others as setting a potentially destabilizing precedent and challenging the Trust’s governance balance.
The matter has drawn the attention of senior members of the government, who have informally urged the Trusts’ leadership to maintain unity in the interest of financial-market stability and continuity at one of India’s most systemically significant business houses.
While recent meetings have been described as cordial, the underlying questions remain unresolved. The outcome will shape not only the future composition of the Trusts but also the governance architecture of the wider Tata Group, especially at a sensitive moment following the passing of Ratan Tata and the transition to a new leadership era.
Also Read: Justice Surya Kant Set to Take Charge as CJI
