Mohammed Siraj’s exclusion from India’s playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand has triggered a political controversy, with allegations of religious discrimination adding a new dimension to the debate over the team management’s selection decision. Congress MP Imran Masood questioned whether Siraj was overlooked because of his Muslim identity, while the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) strongly rejected the allegation, insisting that cricket selection should not be linked to religion or politics.
The controversy has also drawn criticism from several prominent figures in Indian cricket, including former India captains Mohammad Azharuddin and Sunil Gavaskar, former head coach Ravi Shastri and former spinner Ravichandran Ashwin. Their objections have centred on Siraj’s experience, performances and ability to deliver in challenging Test conditions.
India left the experienced fast bowler out of the playing XI for the opening Test against New Zealand at Wellington’s Basin Reserve on November 19. Captain Shubman Gill and head coach Gautam Gambhir opted for a four-man pace attack comprising Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna. Siraj and Gurnoor Brar were among the players left out.
The decision surprised many observers, particularly given Siraj’s contribution to India’s Test bowling attack over the past few years.
Congress MP Imran Masood was among the first political leaders to question the selection. Speaking to news agency ANI on Friday, the Saharanpur MP suggested that Siraj had been denied a place despite his performances because of his name.
“His name is Siraj, isn’t that reason enough? If he’s performing and still not getting selected, what else could be the reason behind it? This alone can be the reason,” Masood said, implying that religious discrimination was behind the decision.
The remarks quickly turned a cricketing debate into a political confrontation. BJP spokesperson Nalin Kohli strongly criticised the Congress leader, describing his comments as communal and dismissing them as a silly statement.
Kohli maintained that cricket selections were guided by the team’s requirements and priorities, rather than a player’s religious identity. He also pointed out that the selection committee and team management were responsible for deciding the playing combination.
Madhya Pradesh minister and BJP leader Vishwas Sarang also criticised Masood, accusing the Congress MP of bringing religious politics into cricket.
The BJP’s response was equally sharp on social media. Party spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari accused Congress of indulging in vote-bank politics and argued that players should be judged by their contribution to the national team.
The political exchange, however, has taken place alongside genuine questions from former cricketers about the decision to leave Siraj out.
Former India captain Mohammad Azharuddin expressed disappointment over the selection in a post on X. He highlighted Siraj’s contribution, particularly during periods when Jasprit Bumrah was unavailable, and said the fast bowler had consistently demonstrated commitment, ability and fighting spirit.
While wishing Anshul Kamboj well, Azharuddin said Siraj deserved better consideration. He also hoped the team management would explain the decision to the player with the clarity and respect he deserved.
Former India head coach Ravi Shastri also questioned the selection. In a post on X, Shastri highlighted Siraj’s experience, aggression and ability to make things happen with the ball. He questioned why the fast bowler had not been included when pace, skill and seam movement were important considerations.
Sunil Gavaskar, meanwhile, described Siraj’s omission as baffling during the match coverage. He pointed out that the pacer had never let India down and questioned the decision to leave him out of the four-man pace attack.
Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin also criticised the decision, describing Siraj’s exclusion as absolutely crazy.
The numbers further explain why Siraj’s omission attracted attention. According to Wisden figures cited in reports, he is India’s leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle, with 43 wickets from 11 matches at an average of 26.81. He also claimed 23 wickets during India’s five-Test tour of England in 2025.
His performances in overseas conditions have established him as a dependable member of India’s pace attack. His ability to bowl extended spells, maintain pressure and generate movement has made him a valuable option in Test cricket.
The team management, however, has defended its decision as a tactical choice. At the pre-match press conference, Gill acknowledged that leaving out Siraj and Gurnoor was difficult, explaining that the management had spent considerable time considering the right combination.
Gill also referred to the batting ability of players such as Akash Deep and Kamboj as one of the factors in assessing the team’s overall balance.